Earl Grey’s Irish Famine Orphans; Origins of the scheme

I’m very new to this so please forgive my booboos.

Here’s a little picture. Note the bulge in the graph, the percentage of 10-24 year old Irish female migrants arriving in New South Wales. This is explained by the arrival of c. 3,500 famine orphans from Irish workhouses who came to Port Jackson and Port Phillip between 1848 and 1850. It does not include the 600 who sailed into Port Adelaide. There were 4114-4175,  mostly adolescent  females in all, who came as part of the “Earl Grey Scheme”.

 

Viewing a graph like this illustrates just how remarkable a feat of British Imperial social engineering the  Earl Grey scheme was. One can imagine the conversation at the centre of power. “Do the Australian colonies need more females? Yes, well let’s send them some from our workhouses.”  Not that it was ever as simple as that.

ORIGINS

Where did the idea come from? It was not completely new. An important precedent  was set during the 1830s when young women, many of them from both Irish and English Foundling Hospitals,  Houses of Industry and other charitable institutions, were brought into New South Wales and Van Diemen’s Land. The aim  of the British Imperial government,  as Lord Howick put it, was to “encourage the emigration of females”‘  “to remedy what is so very serious an evil in its present condition (the disproportion of the sexes)”. (Howick to Treasury 16 Feb 1831, quoted in British Parliamentary Report of 1835). This  motive was still very much in evidence  in 1848. As indeed was  the speed with which commentators in both Britain and Australia stereotyped such female emigration as “being injurious to the best interests of the colony”  (J. Eckfort, Surgeon on board the Duchess of Northumberland, giving evidence to  the Parliamentary enquiry in 1835). His sentiments  echoed those of the Presbyterian Minister, Reverend J. D Lang, who earlier that same week had  asserted to the Enquiry that “the female emigrants sent out by Government…although many of them have conducted themselves reputably, and are now comfortably settled, their general influence on the morals of the colony has been decidedly and highly unfavourable”.  (On the fifteen vessels which came from Ireland and England in the 1830s  see A. J. Hammerton’s essay in (Australian) Historical Studies in October 1975 and more recently,  Liz Rushen’s books. Her Colonial Duchesses,  on mainly Irish women, is published by Anchor Books in 2014. See her website www.rushen.com.au ) This early government scheme for bringing women to Australia had finished by 1836.

There was, however, an enormous influx of Irish women as Bounty migrants in the early 1840s.  Between January 1841 and June 1842 almost  17, 000 Assisted Irish immigrants arrived in New South Wales. More than half of them were female. The authorities were hard pressed to find initial accommodation and employment  for such a flood of people.  Caroline Chisholm, “The Emigrant’s Friend”, is deservedly renowned for her work with these immigrants. She met them at the wharves, advocated for, and set up a Female Immigrant’s Home and employment agency, promoted the establishment of depots at Liverpool, Parramatta, Campbelltown and Bathurst and travelled herself by dray taking groups of individuals to the hinterland for employment and supervising their terms of work agreement.  However, her ability to publicize her own good work in pamphlets such as Female Immigration:Female Immigration considered in a Brief Account of the Sydney Immigrants’ Home (Sydney, 1842) and Comfort for the Poor! Meat Three Times a Day!!! Voluntary Information from the People of New South Wales collected in that Colony in 1845-6, (London, 1847)  and before various parliamentary enquiries has tended to overshadow the  achievement of  Francis Merewether, the New South Wales Immigration Agent (from 1841-51). He especially, was instrumental in preparing an administrative infrastructure–immigrant depots in Sydney and rural districts, making hiring arrangements– that was resurrected when Government Assisted Immigration recommenced in 1847.

Caroline Chisholm was  a strong advocate of family values and the importance of careful selection of migrants. “Under a good system the very best girls would emigrate”, she emphasized to the New South Wales Legislative Council Select Committee on Immigration in September 1845.  The very next day, 5 September, Francis Merewether also stressed how important female immigration was but it was he who suggested to the Committee, “I am informed that the difficulty of procuring female servants for the Colony is very great, and certainly those sent out during the past eighteen months were generally very inferior in every respect to the male immigrants. Some of the female orphan institutions of the Mother Country  might perhaps supply useful servants: but I am not sufficiently informed upon the subject to do more than throw out the suggestion.”  (My italics)  Merewether dealt with, cared for and distributed throughout the colony of New South Wales a much larger number of migrants than Caroline Chisholm ever did.

Yet Caroline Chisholm undoubtedly had influence on the formulation of British Imperial government’s emigration policy in the period between 1846 and 1848,  at the very time when government assisted emigration was being renewed.  She and her family had returned to England in 1846.  She herself appeared before a House of Lords Select Committee on Colonization from Ireland in July 1847 and submitted “I should not feel the Interest I do in Female Emigration if I did not look beyond providing Families with Female Servants–if i did not know how much they are required as Wives,  and how much moral Good may be done in this Way.” Her quintessential Victorian values  coincided with those in her network of friends and politicians. She was adept at gaining publicity for herself and in promoting what we might call ‘family reunion’. She also forcefully argued the case for the emigration of single females and for the proper treatment of newly arrived migrants, no mean feat.  Yet nowhere have I seen where she  recommended sending female migrants from Irish workhouses.

However, a direct appeal was made by Archibald Cunninghame, a pastoralist  sent by his fellow colonists of the Port Phillip District to appear before that same House of Lords Select Committee on Colonisation.  On 12 and 16 July 1847 Cunninghame presented a detailed and attractive plan for the emigration of Irish orphans, both male and female. While his proposal differed from the one that was eventually put forward by the Colonial Land and Emigration Commissioners early in 1848, not least on the question of who was to pay, there are enough similarities between his scheme and the one that was adopted for us to realize he had a formative influence on what became known as Earl Grey’s Irish female orphan scheme.  “And Orphan Girls, whose fate in this Country one can scarcely think of without a Shudder, would when their Apprenticeship in the Colony had expired find a ready and well-paid Demand for their Labour as single Girls, and the Certainty, if well conducted, of soon being respectably married” (A. Cunninghame Esq., before Select Committee 16 July 1847).

It is clear that the idea of sending orphans from Irish workhouses was ‘in the air’ among parliamentarians in both England and Australia at this time.  Earl Grey, Secretary of State for the Colonies, had received a similar suggestion directly  from Governor Fitzroy in New South Wales and  from Governor Robe of South Australia. According to Archibald Boyd, when he was trying to persuade Earl Grey that British funds should be used to finance emigration to Australia, “the noble lord professed to have been there and then struck with a thought…the orphan girls whom the famine of Ireland had cast upon the parishes of that part of the kingdom, it might perhaps be advantageous to have a proportion sent out to the Australian colonies, on such terms as would divide the expense between the colonies and the parishes.” (see SMH 13 March 1850).

In the final analysis, responsibility for the Irish female orphan scheme lay with Earl Grey, Secretary of State for the colonies in Lord John Russell’s Whig government. It was Grey’s decision and his responsibility to set the whole scheme in motion. The point I’m also making is that the decision to send female orphans was made by the Imperial government but it was not a dictatorial whim, something which Earl Grey plucked out of the blue as the fancy took him. He had listened to government officials in Australia, Governors Robe and Fitzroy and even perhaps, Immigration Agent Merewether as well as representatives of Australian pastoralists such as  Archibald Cunninghame.

We also need to put the scheme into some sort of context; the “Earl Grey female orphan scheme” was but one of a number of similar ‘schemes’ emerging in the late 1840s.  Other ‘schemes’ included bringing out the children of  previous Bounty migrants to join their parents, if they agreed to come; bringing out members of convicts’ families, if they  desired to come, and trialling  the migration of other ‘orphans’ from the remnants of Dublin and Cork Foundling Hospitals and other charitable institutions, though these last may have had less  choice. Grey even attempted to renew convict transportation, much to the ire of colonists!  But the major interest and major  push was for the revival,  renewal and extension of Government Assisted Emigration, designed to supply agricultural labour and domestic servants for pastoral interests in Australia. At the same time, it was what the Imperial government believed was the right kind of social engineering. We should be aware, too, that the administrative machinery for Government Assisted Emigration (which already drew on the experience of convict transportation and Bounty migration) would be a very useful foundation for the emigration of young teenage  women from Irish workhouses between 1848 and 1850.

There are, of course, other contexts, –the Great Irish Famine, the voyage, what happened to the young women in Australia– but more of that later.

digging for potatoes

ORGANIZATION OF THE SCHEME

Advertisements

29 thoughts on “Earl Grey’s Irish Famine Orphans; Origins of the scheme

  1. Trevor, Dpo you have any more information on Mary McMasters, arrived per Diadem in Melbourne 1850 from Armagh, other members of her family went to America, have a letter from her brother that he sent to her in Tasmanian, ( Mary is my husbands GGGrandmother).
    Regards
    Anita Pennicott

    Like

  2. Hi Trevor, thanks for your email. It was great to hear from you. I am a great fan of your Barefoot and Pregnant and have used it extensively as a reference when creating pages on the PROV Wiki. Now that I am retired, I am hoping to get the opportunity to continue inputting to PROV’s site.
    Regards Christine

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Trevor
      Thank you for replying to my request for information on my Great great grandmother Irish Orphan Mary Loughlin.
      And directing me to this site. My wife and I returned from Ireland in July and were able to locate Mary Loughlin in the Sligo Union Work House register due to the tremendous help of the manager of the County Sligo Historical Section of the County Sligo Library. Mary was one of 22 girls sent to Australia under the Earl Grey Scheme from the workhouse.( We were able to see details in the workhouse weekly minute books)
      The girls travelled to Plymouth then sailed on the Eliza Caroline arriving in Port Phillip in 1850.
      While searching for other Irish Family members in County Kerry I was able to purchase an interesting book that you may be familiar with “The Kerry Girls” Emigration and the Earl Grey Scheme written by Kay Moloney Caball published The History Press Ireland this year (2014). It highlights the story of a number of Kerry girls who would have shared a similar start to our Mary. The thought occures to me that a similar book might be written about the 22 Sligo that sailed to Australia as the second batch from the Sligo Workhouse in 1849.

      Thank you again for taking the time to answer my query, I will now follow you journey on your web site and endevour to learn more about the background to the Irish Famine and it’s effect on early Irish emigration to Australia. Would to happy to assist in any way if required please advise.

      Kind Regards Peter Jones

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks Perry. Will be saying something about Board of Guardian Minute Books in the third post. Do you agree with what I’ve said in the second one? Or maybe I’m not being critical enough of the “imperialists”?

    Like

  4. Rob,
    That would be great to find something more about these elusive women. Are they additions to the ones we know about already? What I found is in Barefoot & Pregnant? vol 2 pp. 397-8. There are two further references in that. See the story of Annie Roper nee Murray per Roman emperor pp 131-2 and also Mary Clark nee Murray p 114 who was in Dunwich Benevolent Asylum, Queensland. Wonder if they were sisters.I have a vague memory that i entered a little bit more to the Roman Emperor on the website when I was looking after it shortly after I went to PRONI 2008(?) see

    Do you know anyone in the South Australia Genealogy and Heraldic society who could help ?
    Best wishes, and many thanks
    Hope to get the next post up before the ‘gathering’ at Hyde Park Barracks on the 31st

    Like

    • Hi Trevor
      Yes,they are!
      I first started being interested in the ‘Earl Grey Orphans” a few years ago when I was trying to trace the parents of my GG-Grandmother, Elizabeth Boyd.born c1833 and arrived in S.A. before 1850. She seems to be a prime candidate to be an orphan ,about the right age and no relatives in Adelaide despite exhaustive research.
      I then started looking for other Boyd’s hoping to find a connection and I am still looking !!
      Anyway I found a Catherine Boyd from Strabane who was kind enough to die in Victoria and so her death certificate gave the necessary evidence for her to be an orphan.

      Perry added her name to the list of orphans on the famine website.

      The other lady is Mary Ann McMullan who married Edward Boyd in Adelaide and later moved to Queensland .Her place of origin is shown as Armagh. Again no Relly’s.
      She may have come from Poyntzpass as did some of the other orphans but that needs further research

      I have been in contact with Pat Roberts from the SAGHS but that was about 3 years ago.
      I have become quite proficient with Irish Family History even though that was not my original intention.

      I will make some investigations about these “Murray” girls and see what I can find.
      I do not have a copy of your books but I can easily refer to them at the local Library.
      I won’t be able to make it to “The Gathering” as I will have to go to Darwin soon, but hope it is a success and I will keep you informed of the results of my research.

      Best Wishes
      Rob

      Like

      • Thanks Rob. Thanks to the wisdom and foresight of the former Deputy Keeper of Public Records Northern Ireland, Dr Brian Trainor, many of the Indoor Registers for workhouses, especially in the Six Counties, have been preserved. As far as I know they are held in the Public Record Office in the Titanic Centre in Belfast. It is different in the Republic where records are now decentralised. I’ve only seen the Dublin Indoor Registers and as far as I know there aren’t too many others, perhaps Rathdrum(?) and Kinsale(?)
        But as most of the young women on the “Roman Emperor” came from Northern Workhouses, we might be able to find something.

        Maybe someday someone would check the list of workhouses they came from (see Barefoot, 2, p.397) and then look for young women in surviving Indoor Registers say between the ages of 15 and 20 who may have left their workhouse about a week or ten days before their vessel sailed from Plymouth. The Rom. Emp. sailed 27 July 1848. It would be’guess’ or ‘ghost’list(?). I did have a quick stab at that when last I visited those archives in 2008 and would have put up on the website what i found. But it was a quick visit in 2008 and probably needs someone there to do it properly.
        Look forward to your findings. best wishes
        trevor

        Like

      • Dear Trevor, On my trips to Ireland I’m slowly checking the surviving Indoor Registers as well as the Minute Books. Lots of good organisational stuff in the Minute Books but little on individual names etc. Slowly the stories are coming together

        Like

  5. Dear Trevor,
    Very interesting.
    I have the names of a few girls that I think may have come to South Australia on “Roman Emperor” in 1848
    They all seem to have “materialized” in Adelaide in about 1848.Despite extensive research I have not been able to find parents or siblings or any other relatives for that matter who could have come out with them They were all in their teens and all came from Ireland.
    I have looked at your list of “possibles” and for a number of them I cannot find any evidence of them ever living in South Australia. I have also checked Victorian BDM’s as well, as Victoria was the most likely place for them to go in the early1850’s

    I would appreciate your comments

    Kind Regards

    Rob

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Hi Trevor,
    Thanks for your reply and opinion. Yes we will agree to disagree of course, although I feel Cormac O’ Grada (with all due respect) is somewhat a revisionist. I will be following your work. Take care and good luck.
    Regards, Joe.

    Like

  7. Hi Trevor,
    Good luck with your blog. Very interesting.
    ——————————————————————————–
    From: jmecan@hotmail.co.uk
    Subject: The waifs of Wexford.

    The waif’s of Wexford.
    ————–
    Those stone grey walls, that workhouse grim,
    I gazed upon this day.
    Beneath Loch Garman’s black clouds,
    to hunger times I strayed,
    Haunted now by what I read
    by those who chronicled that dread,
    the misery spawned within now silent walls.
    This mind of mine joined with the fear,
    the orphans screams and cries I heard,
    when burly matron turned them from their beds.
    The scowling too by scowling nurse,
    The Reverend priest, the Nun that cursed,
    those innocents knew not what day would bring.

    Some orphaned too just hours before,
    stood ill clad on a cold flagstone floor,
    Not one was told,” today is your dispatching.”
    The waifs of Wexford workhouse stood,
    Each ragamuffin cold and blue,
    To be presented with their paltry ration.
    With ragged sack and ragged clothes,
    With streaming eyes and running nose,
    This day the girls would leave their native land.
    That day they were Australia bound,
    to work and slave colonial ground,
    to face the constant scorn of nasty preachers.
    Too young to ever understand,
    the vile corruption of that land,
    The leering eyes of men who wished to stain them.

    Malnourished by their lack of food,
    Married, sold to men uncouth,
    Without development to bear their children.
    Some would survive and some would die,
    Some too succumb to suicide, in preference to their misery in life.
    When next you marvel at those walls,
    admiring architectural halls,
    Remember that each grey stone witnessed sin.
    The exportations of the child within.
    ,

    Like

      • Hello Trevor,
        This poem is my own work as I have a big interest in the Gorta Mor/ Great hunger/ and the events of the time. I have many poems written with regard to the era of the ‘Famine’. I am of the belief that the word “famine” is a word that is misleading and that our people past and present have misled and falsely taught the whole truth in our Irish schools over the years that millions of our forebears died of starvation because the potato crop failed, It bewilders me that the people of Ireland and indeed the pupil, including myself, that am now in my early sixties did not ask the question,….”What happened the other foods that were exported to feed the rest of Britain whilst we died in the ditches? I have written many poems on the ‘hunger’ years in the hope of one day publishing and making it easier for the uninformed pupil to digest the poem and question the actual actions of those in power at the time and their laissez faire policies in the interests of commercialism to the detriment of our forebears. Many of my poems can be found by Googling , Joe Canning poetry.
        My poems or verse can be found on the wordpress of a brilliant informative site called. ‘Stair na hEireann’ on facebook..I would be failing in truth if I said to you that I believe the actions of the time were tantamount to genocide, if not in fact genocide. I am an Admin of a petition on the subject of the Great Hunger that is trying to get future generations including an ever learning Diaspora to tell the world of the acyual hell Ireland’s people endured at the hands of people like Trevelyan. John Russell’s Whig Govt. and indeed the underhand and conniving tactics of the likes of the Earl Grey to make his programme of ‘ethnic cleansing look respectable. I applaud you for you work. I am of the opinion that the world must know the truth and that people like you and I are putting it out there in our own way. It would be misleading of me to not tell you about an existing petition http://www.petitions24.com/when_famine_became_genocide_ireland_1845_1850 I wish you nothing but success in this venture and hope to hear from you. Kind regards, Joe Canning.

        Like

      • We’re going to have to agree to disagree on this Joe. I’m more persuaded by the evidence and arguments presented by Irish historians such as Cormac O’Grada, Liam Kennedy, David Fitzpatrick–there’s quite a long list–.
        I’ve been impressed by the work of historical geographers recently, particularly the “Atlas of the Great Irish Famine” eds., Crowley, Smyth and Murphy and David Nally’s “Human Encumbrances”. The views expressed there don’t always sit easily with one another. But I’ve always believed history is about different interpretations and debate. That’s why i find it endlessly fascinating.

        Like

  8. Well done Trevor. I for one will be following your project with great interest. My Great Grandmother arrived on the Panama on the 12th January, 1850. Very interesting reading. Kindest Regards

    Like

      • Hi Trevor, Her name was Mary Browne from Ballina, Co Mayo, born 1833. She went on to marry Richard Cooke at Armidale, New South Wales on 14th March 1853. He was an overseer on Newstead and Wellingrove Stations, NSW and Warkon Station, Queensland. They eventually settled at “Mossdale” Goombungee, Queensland. She died on the 2nd April 1898. I’m guessing you wanted further information on my Great Grandmother? Kindest Regards, Jan

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s